Atlantic salmon
Salmo salar
What to check for
Location
All areas, All areas, Scotland
Production method
Open net pen, marine
Certification
GLOBALG.A.P.
Rating summary
Atlantic salmon are farmed in open net pens in the sea. Producing fish in open systems can cause environmental impacts. The GLOBALG.A.P. standard mitigates many areas of environmental concern, including discharge of effluents, use of chemicals, escapes, disease and parasite interactions. However, lethal control of predators is permitted. The GLOBALG.A.P. standard has criteria in place for welfare and humane slaughter. The GLOBALG.A.P. feed standard has criteria that requires reporting on the amount of responsibly sourced ingredients but no requirement for their percentage inclusion. Due to the lack of data in relation to some of the environmental impacts of salmon farming, MCS is advocating a halt in industry expansion using existing practices until more evidence is available.This rating is based on full compliance with certification requirements. Commercial buyers should therefore ensure that full compliance has been achieved in order for this rating to be applicable. Rating last updated April 2023.
Technical consultation summary
Atlantic salmon are farmed in open net pens in the sea. Producing fish in open systems can cause environmental impacts. The GLOBALG.A.P. standard mitigates many areas of environmental concern, including discharge of effluents, use of chemicals, escapes, disease and parasite interactions. However, lethal control of predators is permitted. The GLOBALG.A.P. standard has criteria in place for welfare and humane slaughter. The GLOBALG.A.P. feed standard has criteria that requires reporting on the amount of responsibly sourced ingredients but no requirement for their percentage inclusion. Due to the lack of data in relation to some of the environmental impacts of salmon farming, MCS is advocating a halt in industry expansion using existing practices until more evidence is available.
How we worked out this Rating
Feed
What feed is given to farmed fish, where it comes from and how much is used is one of the most important aspects of fish farming. In this section we look at how sustainable the feed is and how much fish is included in the diet.
Criteria on responsible feed are lacking in the GLOBALG.A.P. aquaculture standard with currently no requirements for responsible ingredient sourcing. However, the updated Feed Mill standard is expected to lead to improvements.The production of farmed Atlantic salmon relies on a variety of different feeds, including specialist formulation. Historically, the most important ingredients in salmon feed have been fishmeal and fish oil, which provide an almost optimal complete feed in a convenient and highly digestible product form. The primary fisheries supplying fishmeal and fish oil are found globally (Ireland, Denmark, Iceland, South Africa, Norway, Peru, USA) and have a range of species (including anchovy, blue marlin, capelin, menhaden, Norway pout, sand eel, sprat). Due to a need to reduce costs and secure the supply, cheaper alternative ingredients (such as soybean, palm oil, and rapeseed oil) have been progressively substituted in commercial feed formulas.The GLOBALG.A.P. aquaculture standard requires ingredients used in aquaculture feed to be traceable to species level. However, criteria for the sustainable content of feed are lacking and as a minor must, wild fish ingredients which originate from MarinTrust and MSC certified fisheries must only be declared as a minor must.The dependency of wild caught fish used in fishmeal and fish oil (known as the Feed Fish Dependency Ratio) for salmon currently indicates that more fish protein is required in the diet than these fish produce, making them a net consumer of fish rather than a fish producer.There is currently no requirement for soy products and palm oil to be sourced sustainably in the GLOBALG.A.P. standard. There is also no mention of the use of novel or alternative feed ingredients.
Environment
The environmental impacts of aquaculture depend on what fish is farmed, how and where. It could be habitat damage, chemical use, pollution, freshwater use or parasites. In this section we look at the environmental impacts of greatest concern for that species and production method. Some species, such as shellfish, have very little impact, whilst others may give us cause for concern.
Salmon farming in marine open net pens has negative impacts on the marine environment. Mitigation measures are in place within the GLOBALG.A.P. farm standard that partially address these environmental impacts.Habitat alteration in salmon farming is small scale through the use of mooring grids only. The GLOBALG.A.P. standard requires farmers to prove compliance with any applicable environmental regulations for construction and operation of the farm. Discharges do occur from salmon farms and they have a measurable negative impact, however, within the GLOBALG.A.P. standard, these occur within a defined allowable zone of effect.Chemicals are used in salmon farming and while the GLOBALG.A.P. standard limits the frequency in which they can be used, there is a lack of specific criteria in place surrounding the use of pesticides and no restrictions on the amount of chemicals that can be used per production cycle.Disease outbreaks do occur globally but the impact of these is not thought to threaten regional level operations. There is also a problem with sea lice parasites globally and the GLOBALG.A.P. standard has a veterinary health plan in place to mitigate the impacts of parasites. This is not thought to be fully effective and it is not known if the veterinary health plan has had an impact on parasite transfer.The design of open net pen salmon farms means that there is the potential for fish to escape. However, the GLOBALG.A.P. standard requires a documented procedure for preventing escapes, and reporting to show mitigation measures in place to prevent further escapes.All juveniles used in salmon aquaculture are hatchery based. However, wild caught cleaner fish are used. The GLOBALG.A.P. standard does not have requirements for cleaner fish to come from sustainable populations. Wildlife interactions also occur in salmon farms, including birds and marine mammals. The GLOBALG.A.P. standard requires an effective predator control plan, however, lethal control is allowed if necessary.
Fish health and welfare
Fish health and welfare is a concern for many consumers. High welfare standards are an indication of good farm management, we look to see if there are industry wide welfare standards in place, and if these include humane slaughter.
GLOBALG.A.P. has criteria in place to ensure animal welfare and humane slaughter.The GLOBALG.A.P. standard outlines practices that are in place to ensure animal welfare and humane slaughter, including a welfare risk assessment.
Management
How aquaculture is regulated and how effective those regulations are is an important aspect of farmed fish production. We also look to see if aquaculture is included in broader environmental management plans. In this management section we also award scores for globally recognised certification standards, as certified seafood requires verification of environmental performance and traceability.
GLOBALG.A.P. farmed salmon are well managed and management is thought to be fully effective.This assessment covers Atlantic salmon from Scotland, Norway and the Faroe Islands, farmed to the GLOBALG.A.P. certification. The certification criteria covers farm level environmental impact assessment, identification and protection of valuable habitats and species, use of land and water resources, use of chemicals, discharges, biosecurity, disease management and species introduction. The regulations are mostly effective, however, there are still high levels of parasitic transfer of sea lice occurring and it is not known if escapes are continuing to happen from certified farms.There is no requirement for certified farms to be subject to strategic environmental planning, as this is the responsibility of the production country. Each of the countries producing GLOBALG.A.P. certified salmon either have strategic environmental planning in place, or it is in development.The GLOBALG.A.P. Aquaculture Standard incorporates aspects stipulated by the FAO Technical Guidelines on Aquaculture certification and the OIE Aquatic Animal Health Code. It is recognized both by the GFSI for food safety and GSSI at primary production level, covering key sustainability aspects for animal production for human consumption. The score for this section reflects GLOBALG.A.P. certified producers that are in full compliance with the standard.
References
BioMar. 2021. Global Sustainability Report. Available at https://www.biomar.com/globalassets/.global/sustainability-report/en_biomar-global-sustainability-report-2021.pdf [Accessed on 06.04.2023].
Elevancini, J. S. 2017. How do third-party certifications control the use of antibiotics in global salmon aquaculture? College of Sustainability. Dalhousie University. Halifax, Nova Scotia. Available at https://dalspace.library.dal.ca/bitstream/handle/10222/73361/ESS-Thesis-Regulation%20of%20Antibiotics%20in%20Salmon%20Aquaculture-Elevancini.pdf [Accessed on 06.04.2023].
European Commission. 2021. Strategic guidelines for a more sustainable and competitive EU aquaculture for the period 2021 to 2030. Available at https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12261-EU-fish-farms-aquaculture-updated-guidelines_en [Accessed on 06.04.2023].
GLOBALG.A.P. 2022. Integrated Farm Assurance Smart/GFS. Version 6.0 June 2022. Available at https://www.globalgap.org/.content/.galleries/documents/220607_IFA_Smart_GFS_PCs_AQ_interim_final_amended_v6_0_Jun22_en.pdf [Accessed on 06.04.2023].
GLOBALG.A.P. 2016. Compound Feed Manufacturing. Version 2 August 2016. Available at https://www.globalgap.org/.content/.galleries/documents/160805_gg_cfm_cpcc_v2.2_Aug16_en.pdf [Accessed on 06.04.2023].
Hoel, A. H. and Olsen, E. 2010. Marine Spatial Planning: Norway- s management plans. Available at https://imr.brage.unit.no/imr-xmlui/bitstream/handle/11250/102586/O0510.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y [Accessed on 06.04.2023].
Marine Spatial Planning Programme. Norway. Available at http://msp.ioc-unesco.org/world-applications/europe/norway/ [Accessed on 06.04.2023].
Scottish Government. 2015. Scotland- s National Marine Plan. Available at https://www.gov.scot/publications/scotlands-national-marine-plan/ [Accessed on 06.04.2023].
Sustainable swaps
Learn more about how we calculate our sustainability ratings.
How our ratings work
Add impact to your inbox
Join the movement: get updates on the issues you care about.
We'll email you inspiring stories about the work we're doing to save and recover our oceans, and news about our urgent campaigns for positive change.